Primetime Turns A True Story Into A Question: How Much Reality Do We Actually Want To Watch?

A24's Primetime has taken over the theatres with the high praise for Robert Pattison's performance and the film's gritty plot. Even though the film is about the popular host-journalist Chris Hansen, America's celebrated hero, it is not really a hero story. And that is exactly what makes the story brilliant.

Directed by Lance Oppenheim, Robert Pattinson plays Chris Hansen, the face of NBC's infamous 'To Catch a Predator'. Set in 2006, the plot showcases TRP's frenzy and is inspired by the 2007 Esquire article 'Tonight on Dateline This Man Will Die' by Luke Dittrich. However, it does not pretend to be a clean biopic, and the director himself called it closer to a fever dream than an authorised biopic.

Chasing ratings and losing the purpose:

The premise is simple: a team that began a show with a public-service idea, catching online predators using decoys and hidden cameras. Despite its not-being-seen before premise, To Catch A Predator soon began America's biggest guilty pleasure, even going against hit shows like Lost in the TRP battle.  

The problem began when Chris Hansen and his team were expected to make every sting bigger, louder, more dramatic than the last. Because numbers matter more for the networks, even more than following the show's basic premise.

This is where Primetime stops being just an American story and becomes a global one. The original To Catch a Predator started with a noble pitch, which was exposing sexual predators hidden in society and protecting children. However, its real purpose got lost in the race for ratings, and the format became the punishment. Entertainment was prioritised first, but the confrontation and context came later.

 

 

 

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Primetime (@primetimemovie)

How far will reality shows go for TRPs?

The film's darkest turn showed a horrific true incident: the 2006 Suicide of Bill Conradt. When Assistant District Attorney Bill Conradt, who had been chatting online with a decoy, did not show up to the sting house, the police and the camera crew arrived at his home. He shot himself, and this is when the show crossed a line from reporting a crime to staging it.

Primetime doesn't sensationalise the suicide. It lets it sit with you. In the quest to do good, did they end up doing more harm? Even after the tragic suicide, when the team thinks about creating an episode out of it, that’s when you question: how far will you go for TRP?

However, we have seen this playbook everywhere. One of the biggest examples in India is Bigg Boss. It started as entertainment, but now it thrives on exactly what Primetime warns us about: humiliation as content. From Swami Om throwing urine on contestants to Zubair Khan attempting suicide after being publicly shamed by host Salman Khan, the audience knows it is toxic, but the TRP machine needs a new villain every week.

ALSO READ- Bigg Boss 20: Did Rhiti Tiwari Confess To Using Sexual Slurs Against Uditi Singh? Netizens Are Furious

And then there's America's Next Top Model, which was created by Tyra Banks to bring new opportunities for models. However,  Netflix's own 2026 documentary Reality Check showed some shocking insights, including body-shaming, forced makeovers, starvation, and even alleged sexual assault.

One of the most shocking revelations was when one contestant, Shandi Sullivan, revealed that she was filmed during an alleged sexual assault in Milan, and the show aired it as a 'cheating' storyline. A show that was about empowerment, bring new opportunity to young women and revolutionising the modelling industry, became a torture for ratings.

What is the final verdict of Primetime?

Primetime is not here to give you a clean answer on whether Chris Hansen is a hero or a villain. It is here to ask you a more uncomfortable question: How much reality do we actually want to watch?

The show that was supposed to catch predators became predatory itself, feeding on shame, desperation, and our need to watch someone else get exposed.

In 2026, when reality TV shows are bigger than ever, Primetime feels less like a period film and more like an exposé.

(Image Credits: Instagram)
To read more such stories, stay tuned to Her Zindagi.